Key Takeaways
- Personal liability attaches immediately: Under s 588G of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), a director becomes personally liable for debts incurred while the company is insolvent and the director knew, or ought to have known, that insolvency existed.
- Safe harbour offers real protection, if activated properly: Section 588GA provides a complete defence if the director takes reasonable steps to achieve a better outcome for creditors before appointing an insolvency practitioner, but the clock starts ticking from the moment of suspected insolvency.
- Civil penalties doubled from 1 July 2026: The maximum civil penalty for insolvent trading is now $1,820,000 (5,000 penalty units × $364 per unit), in addition to compensation orders for the full amount of the insolvent debts.
- Payday Super creates a new DPN ambush from 1 July 2026: Directors now face 52 potential Director Penalty Notice windows per year (one per weekly pay cycle) for unpaid superannuation, representing an exponential increase in personal liability exposure compared with the pre-Payday Super quarterly cycle.
- The s 95A cash flow test is unforgiving: Insolvency is judged on whether the company can pay its debts as and when they fall due, not on net asset position. A company with substantial assets can still be insolvent if it lacks the liquidity to pay creditors on time.
Introduction: Why Insolvent Trading Is the Biggest Personal Risk for Queensland Directors in 2026
Running a Queensland company in financial difficulty is among the most legally dangerous positions a director can occupy. Unlike shareholders, who generally risk only their invested capital when a company fails, directors face unlimited personal liability for debts incurred during the period of insolvency.
In 2026, that risk has intensified. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has sharpened its enforcement focus on director liability, the Payday Super regime that commenced on 1 July 2026 has created new personal liability windows that did not exist before, and the maximum civil penalty for insolvent trading now stands at $1,820,000.
This guide is for Queensland company directors who need to understand exactly what insolvent trading means, when personal liability attaches, what defences are available, and what practical steps to take right now if the company is showing signs of financial distress. It covers the law as it stands in the second half of 2026, including legislative changes that came into force on 1 July 2026.
If you are a director of a Queensland company and the company is struggling to pay its debts, speak with an insolvency lawyer in Brisbane before the situation becomes irreversible. The timing of when you get advice is often the difference between preserving the safe harbour defence and losing it entirely.
What Is Insolvent Trading? The Legal Framework Under the Corporations Act
The s 95A Insolvency Test
Under s 95A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), a company is insolvent if, and only if, it is unable to pay all its debts as and when they become due and payable. This is the cash flow test, not a balance sheet test.
The cash flow test is deliberately strict. A company may have substantial assets, including real property, plant and equipment, receivables, yet still be insolvent for the purposes of s 95A if it cannot meet its obligations to creditors as they fall due. ASIC and liquidators routinely use the gap between actual payment dates and due dates as evidence of insolvency.
Courts applying s 95A look at:
- The company’s current bank balances and available credit facilities
- Cash flow projections for the following weeks and months
- Overdue creditor accounts and the age of outstanding invoices
- Whether the company is stretching payment terms without creditor consent
- The company’s ability to refinance or raise equity capital in the short term
- ATO debt, including GST arrears, PAYG withholding, and superannuation guarantee charge
Director Liability Under s 588G
Section 588G of the Corporations Act imposes a personal duty on each director not to incur a debt when the company is insolvent, or when incurring the debt would make the company insolvent, if at the time of incurring the debt the director knew there were reasonable grounds to expect insolvency, or a reasonable person in a like position would have known.
The phrase “reasonable person in a like position” is important. It means the subjective ignorance of a director who failed to review financial statements, attend board meetings, or engage with management accounts is not a defence. The law holds directors to the standard of the reasonably informed director who does their job.
The consequences of a successful insolvent trading claim are severe:
- Compensation: The director is personally liable to compensate the company (and through it, creditors) for the amount of the insolvent debts, being every debt incurred while the company was insolvent during the director’s watch.
- Civil penalty: ASIC may seek a civil penalty of up to $1,820,000 (5,000 penalty units at $364 per unit, the rate from 1 July 2026) or three times the benefit obtained, whichever is greater.
- Criminal liability: Where the director’s conduct is dishonest, s 588G(3) exposes the director to criminal prosecution and a sentence of up to five years imprisonment.
- Disqualification: ASIC may apply to disqualify a director found liable for insolvent trading under s 206C or s 206D.
The 2026 Update: Payday Super and the Director Penalty Notice Intersection
Prior to 1 July 2026, employers were required to pay superannuation guarantee contributions quarterly. This meant a director could, in theory, fall behind on four cycles per year before facing the risk of a lockdown Director Penalty Notice (DPN) for SGC liabilities.
From 1 July 2026, Payday Super requires employers to pay superannuation guarantee contributions on the same day as salary and wages, effectively every pay cycle. For most Queensland businesses paying staff weekly, this creates 52 potential DPN exposure windows per year instead of four.
The intersection with insolvent trading is direct:
- If a director knows the company cannot meet Payday Super obligations but continues trading and incurring debts, this is evidence that the director knew or ought to have known of insolvency.
- Once a DPN is issued and the 21-day response window closes without the director taking the required action (paying the debt, appointing an administrator, or winding up), the ATO debt crystallises as a personal liability of the director under the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth).
- Where SGC liabilities have been outstanding for more than three months, the ATO issues a lockdown DPN, a notice that cannot be avoided by voluntary administration or winding up after the fact. The director must pay personally, full stop.
- The ATO’s collection posture in 2026 is aggressive: over 84,000 DPNs were issued in FY2026, and the ATO collected over $2.1 billion through the DPN regime in that financial year.
For Queensland directors, the practical consequence is that the moment a company falls behind on Payday Super obligations, the clock is running simultaneously on both the DPN regime and the insolvent trading analysis. Directors who wait to seek legal advice until the first DPN arrives may already have lost the safe harbour window. Speak with a director disputes lawyer in Brisbane at the first sign of SGC payment difficulty.
The Four Defences Under s 588H
Section 588H of the Corporations Act provides four statutory defences to an insolvent trading claim. Each defence requires careful evidence and documentation, and none are available to a director who has simply been inattentive.
| Defence | Section | What the Director Must Prove | Key Evidentiary Requirements |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reasonable grounds to believe solvency | s 588H(2) | At the time of incurring each debt, the director had reasonable grounds to believe the company was solvent and would remain so after incurring the debt | Board minutes reflecting genuine solvency analysis; current financial statements; professional accounting advice; cash flow forecasts |
| Reliance on competent person | s 588H(3) | The director relied on information provided by a competent person (usually the CFO or external accountant) that gave reasonable grounds to believe solvency | Written CFO/accountant reports; board minutes recording receipt; evidence the information was actually reviewed and acted upon |
| Illness or other good reason for non-participation | s 588H(4) | The director did not participate in management because of illness or some other good reason and, because of such non-participation, did not know the grounds existed | Medical evidence; documented leave from management role; evidence of delegation to competent co-director |
| Reasonable steps to prevent loss | s 588H(5) | The director took all reasonable steps to prevent the company from incurring the debt, including by taking action to appoint a voluntary administrator under Part 5.3A | Evidence of director actions: calling creditors meetings, engaging turnaround advisors, initiating VA appointment; board minutes |
The most commonly litigated defence is the reasonable grounds to believe solvency defence under s 588H(2). Courts look at the totality of information available to the director at the relevant time, not what the director wished or hoped was true. The cases of ASIC v Rich and the James Hardie litigation both turned in significant part on what board members knew or ought to have known at the relevant time, even where individual directors argued they relied on management representations.
Safe Harbour: The s 588GA Defence in Depth
Section 588GA of the Corporations Act was introduced in 2017 and represents a significant policy shift, being an acknowledgment that the threat of insolvent trading liability was deterring directors from attempting genuine restructuring efforts. The safe harbour is a complete defence to civil liability under s 588G, but it is not automatic. It must be actively earned and maintained.
When Safe Harbour Applies
Safe harbour applies when a director starts developing one or more courses of action that are reasonably likely to lead to a better outcome for the company than immediate voluntary administration or winding up. A “better outcome” is assessed against the situation the company and its creditors would be in if an insolvency practitioner were appointed immediately.
Critically, the protection covers only debts incurred directly in connection with the course of action taken. If the director is pursuing a genuine restructure but also incurring debts that are unconnected with that restructure, for example continuing to extend credit to an associated party. Those debts fall outside the safe harbour.
Requirements to Maintain Safe Harbour
Section 588GA(4) sets out conditions that must be met for the safe harbour to apply. The director must ensure that:
- Employee entitlements are being paid when due, including wages, superannuation (now on a Payday basis from 1 July 2026), and annual leave entitlements
- The company’s tax reporting obligations are being met, including PAYG withholding, BAS, and SGC returns must be lodged even if the tax cannot be paid immediately
- The director is seeking appropriate advice from a suitably qualified advisor, whether a restructuring lawyer, restructuring advisor, or insolvency practitioner
- The director is keeping proper records of the course of action being developed and the basis on which the director reasonably believes it will lead to a better outcome
The Payday Super regime has tightened the employee entitlements condition significantly. Under the pre-1 July 2026 quarterly SGC cycle, a director might fall one quarterly cycle behind on superannuation and still maintain the safe harbour. Under Payday Super, falling even one weekly cycle behind on SGC places the safe harbour at immediate risk. Directors in financial difficulty must treat Payday Super obligations as non-negotiable.
The s 588GB Restriction
Section 588GB prevents a director from using the safe harbour defence in proceedings if the company has failed to comply with its financial reporting obligations (s 286 of the Corporations Act). This is the lesson from Crispino v Lightowler [2026] VSC 500, where a director was ordered to pay $2,504,836.99 for insolvent trading after failing to maintain proper financial records. The s 588E(4) presumption of insolvency that applies when financial records are inadequate makes it nearly impossible to run a solvency defence. Proper bookkeeping is not optional. It is a precondition to any defence.
The Business Judgment Rule: An Overlooked Intersection
The business judgment rule under s 180(2) of the Corporations Act provides that a director satisfies the duty of care and diligence in respect of a business judgment if the director:
- Makes the judgment in good faith and for a proper purpose
- Does not have a material personal interest in the subject matter of the judgment
- Informs themselves about the subject matter of the judgment to the extent they reasonably believe appropriate
- Rationally believes the judgment is in the best interests of the company
The business judgment rule does not, however, provide a defence to an insolvent trading claim under s 588G. The High Court’s analysis in the James Hardie litigation confirms that insolvent trading liability is governed by its own regime under Pt 5.7B of the Corporations Act, and s 180(2) operates separately.
Where the business judgment rule is most relevant to directors in financial difficulty is in demonstrating that the decision to continue trading, rather than immediately appointing an administrator, was a genuine, informed business judgment made on reasonable grounds. This overlaps with, but does not replicate, the s 588H(2) solvency belief defence and the s 588GA safe harbour. Wise directors document their decision-making at every stage, treating each board resolution as potential evidence in future litigation.
The Centrepoint Alliance Warning: How Courts Assess Director Knowledge
The Centrepoint Alliance litigation is frequently cited in insolvent trading cases for the proposition that courts will scrutinise what information was actually available to directors, not what directors claim they did not receive. In that litigation, the court was prepared to find that reasonable directors in the positions of the accused, with access to the financial information that was available, would have appreciated the company’s insolvency.
For Queensland directors, the practical lesson is that ignorance of the company’s financial position is rarely a defence. If you are a director, you are expected to be informed. Signing financial statements without reading them, delegating all financial oversight to a co-director without adequate monitoring, or failing to attend board meetings where financial performance is discussed will not insulate you from liability.
ASIC’s 2026 Enforcement Posture: What the Statistics Show
ASIC’s enforcement priorities in 2026 have included a renewed focus on director misconduct in the context of insolvency. The agency has publicly stated that insolvent trading, phoenix activity, and creditor-defeating dispositions are among its highest enforcement priorities. Key enforcement actions in 2026 have included:
- The first-ever criminal charge for a creditor-defeating disposition under s 588GAC(1) of the Corporations Act, brought in June 2026
- Continued disqualification orders against directors who have allowed companies to incur debts while insolvent and then walked away from the resulting liabilities
- Compensation orders being sought through liquidators in cases where the director has personal assets sufficient to satisfy a judgment
The practical implication is that insolvent trading liability is not a theoretical risk. In 2026, ASIC and liquidators are actively pursuing directors, and the courts are awarding significant compensation orders. The $1,820,000 civil penalty cap is the upper limit, but courts are also awarding unlimited compensation equal to the full amount of the insolvent debts, which in complex cases can be in the millions of dollars.
A Practical Action Guide for Queensland Directors Today
If your Queensland company is showing signs of financial distress, the following steps are not optional. They are the minimum required to protect your personal position.
Step 1: Get Current Financial Information
You cannot assess solvency without current financial data. If the company’s books are more than four weeks behind, bring them up to date immediately. A cash flow forecast covering the next 13 weeks is the minimum baseline for assessing whether the company can pay its debts as and when they fall due under s 95A.
Step 2: Identify All Creditor Obligations and Due Dates
Map every creditor obligation including trade creditors, secured lenders, ATO liabilities (GST, PAYG, SGC), employee entitlements (wages, Payday Super, annual leave, long service leave), and any personal guarantees you have given to the company’s lenders. The gap between what is owed and what can be paid from cash on hand determines whether the company is currently insolvent for s 95A purposes.
Step 3: Identify Whether You Are in the Safe Harbour Window
If the company may be insolvent, you need to determine whether a course of action is available that is reasonably likely to lead to a better outcome than immediate administration or winding up. This requires advice from a qualified restructuring advisor, not a friend or a general commercial advisor. The safe harbour must be activated before liability has crystallised in respect of each debt. It cannot be applied retrospectively.
Step 4: Document Everything
Every decision you make from this point forward must be documented. Board minutes, written financial advice, correspondence with creditors and advisors, and cash flow models. All of this is potential evidence. Courts and liquidators scrutinise the contemporaneous record. If the only evidence of your decision-making is your uncorroborated oral testimony years after the fact, you are in a very difficult position.
Step 5: Address Payday Super Immediately
If Payday Super obligations are not being met, this is an emergency. Speak with a director liability lawyer immediately. The gap between the day the SGC obligation arose and the day a DPN is issued can be measured in days under the new regime. The difference between a lockdown DPN and a non-lockdown DPN (and therefore between a debt you can avoid by appointing an administrator and one you cannot) may depend on action taken within the next 48 to 72 hours.
Step 6: Get Independent Legal Advice
General commercial lawyers are not insolvency lawyers. If your company is facing potential insolvency, you need advice from a lawyer who practices regularly in insolvent trading claims, director liability, and voluntary administration. Mark Harley, Doyle’s Guide recommended, and the team at Boss Lawyers advise directors on insolvency, director disputes, and personal liability in distressed situations. If litigation by a liquidator becomes a risk, the commercial litigation team can advise on defence strategy, negotiation, and contribution claims against co-directors.
Co-Director Liability: What Happens When One Director Acts, One Does Not
Each director bears personal responsibility under s 588G. The fact that a co-director was “running the finances” or “making all the decisions” does not automatically relieve a passive director of liability. A passive director must still demonstrate that they had reasonable grounds to believe the company was solvent (s 588H(2)) or that their non-participation was the result of illness or another good reason (s 588H(4)).
Importantly, directors who are found jointly liable for insolvent trading may have contribution claims against each other. Where one director is the primary decision-maker and another director can demonstrate they relied in good faith on representations from that director, contribution claims between co-directors, and potentially against professional advisors, may be available. This is another reason why early, documented legal advice is essential.
What to Do If a Liquidator Has Already Made Contact
If a company has already gone into liquidation and a liquidator has written to you alleging insolvent trading liability, you are in a different and more urgent situation. The limitation period for a liquidator’s insolvent trading claim is generally six years from the date of liquidation, so receiving a letter of demand from a liquidator does not necessarily mean that legal proceedings are imminent, but it does mean you need legal advice immediately.
Key steps once a liquidator makes contact:
- Do not respond without legal advice. Anything you say to a liquidator may be used in subsequent proceedings. Liquidators are experienced in gathering admissions from unrepresented directors.
- Preserve all documents. Financial records, board minutes, emails, and accountant reports from the relevant period are your evidence. Do not destroy, delete, or alter any records.
- Identify the period of alleged insolvency. The liquidator will typically specify the period during which they allege debts were incurred while the company was insolvent. You need to locate and review all financial information from that period.
- Assess the defences available. A director disputes lawyer can assess the strength of the s 588H defences and the safe harbour on the facts of your specific case.
- Consider contribution claims. If there are co-directors and the primary liability rests with another director, you may have a contribution claim against that director or against professional advisors who gave incorrect advice.
Boss Lawyers’ director disputes team and commercial litigation team regularly advise directors facing insolvent trading claims from liquidators, including in cases that proceed to litigation in the Supreme Court of Queensland and Federal Court.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is insolvent trading in Queensland?
Insolvent trading occurs when a director of a Queensland company incurs a debt on behalf of the company at a time when the company is insolvent under s 95A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), meaning unable to pay its debts as and when they fall due, and the director knew or ought to have known of the company’s insolvency. The director becomes personally liable for those insolvent debts under s 588G of the Corporations Act.
What are the defences to an insolvent trading claim?
Section 588H of the Corporations Act provides four statutory defences: (1) the director had reasonable grounds to believe the company was solvent at the time each debt was incurred (s 588H(2)); (2) the director relied on information from a competent person (such as a CFO or external accountant) that gave reasonable grounds to believe the company was solvent (s 588H(3)); (3) the director did not participate in management due to illness or another good reason (s 588H(4)); or (4) the director took all reasonable steps to prevent the company incurring the debt, including by appointing a voluntary administrator (s 588H(5)). Section 588GA also provides a complete safe harbour defence for directors who are taking genuine steps to achieve a better outcome than immediate insolvency.
How does safe harbour protect Queensland directors from insolvent trading liability?
Section 588GA of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) provides a complete defence to civil insolvent trading liability if the director starts developing a course of action that is reasonably likely to lead to a better outcome for the company and its creditors than immediate appointment of an administrator or liquidator. To qualify, the director must ensure employee entitlements (including Payday Super from 1 July 2026) are being paid when due, tax reporting obligations are being met, appropriate restructuring advice is being sought, and proper records of the restructuring plan are kept.
How does Payday Super affect director liability for insolvent trading in 2026?
From 1 July 2026, Payday Super requires employers to pay superannuation guarantee contributions on the same day as wages, creating up to 52 ATO Director Penalty Notice exposure windows per year for weekly payroll businesses, compared with four under the old quarterly SGC cycle. Failing to pay Payday Super is strong evidence of insolvency under s 95A, which also undermines the safe harbour defence under s 588GA, which requires that employee entitlements are paid when due. Directors in financial difficulty should treat Payday Super obligations as the highest-priority payment obligation.
What is the maximum penalty for insolvent trading in 2026?
From 1 July 2026, the maximum civil penalty for insolvent trading under s 588G of the Corporations Act is $1,820,000 (5,000 penalty units at $364 per unit) or three times the benefit obtained, whichever is greater. In addition to civil penalties, a director is liable to compensate creditors for the full amount of the insolvent debts incurred during their watch. Where conduct is dishonest, criminal liability under s 588G(3) applies, carrying a sentence of up to five years imprisonment.
Conclusion: The Cost of Delay Is Personal
Insolvent trading in Queensland is not a mistake that resolves itself. Every day a director continues to incur debts on behalf of an insolvent company without taking protective action is another day of potential personal liability. The law does not wait for the director to be ready. The liquidator’s clock starts running from the first day of insolvency, and the personal consequences, including compensation orders in the hundreds of thousands or millions of dollars, civil penalties up to $1,820,000, and potential criminal prosecution, are all real.
The good news is that the law also provides genuine pathways for directors who act early and correctly. The safe harbour under s 588GA, voluntary administration under Part 5.3A, and the Small Business Restructuring regime under Part 5.3B all offer real options, but only if they are activated before the window closes. If your Queensland company is under financial pressure today, now is the time to act.
For advice on insolvent trading liability, director personal exposure, or the steps available to a Queensland director facing company financial difficulty, contact Mark Harley, Doyle’s Guide recommended, and the team at Boss Lawyers. Insolvency lawyers, director disputes, and commercial litigation, all under one roof in Brisbane.
This is general information only and is not legal advice. You should obtain professional advice specific to your circumstances.





